Post Publication Discussion Policy

Post-Publication Discussion and Corrections Policy

The journal encourages academic debate and scholarly discussion of articles published in our journal. To safeguard the integrity of the scholarly record and provide a platform for scientific dialogue, the Editorial Board facilitates post-publication discussion through the following mechanisms.

1. Submission of Criticism and Corrections

  1. Readers, researchers, or institutions wishing to provide scholarly feedback, raise scientific criticism, or identify potential errors in a published article may submit a Letter to the Editor.
  2. Submissions must be formal, evidence-based, objective, and directly relevant to the methodology, data, or conclusions of the article concerned.
  3. Manuscripts must be submitted by email to the Editorial Office at heritage@yudharta.ac.id.

2. Authors’ Right of Reply

  1. Upon receiving a valid critique, the Editorial Board will notify the original author(s) of the article and provide them with an opportunity to respond (Right to Reply).
  2. Authors’ responses will be reviewed by the editors to ensure that they remain professional and comply with academic standards.
  3. If both the critique and the response pass editorial evaluation, they may be published together in a future issue as part of a comment-and-response section to encourage open scholarly discussion.

3. Handling Errors and Academic Misconduct

If post-publication discussion reveals significant errors, data manipulation, plagiarism, or other ethical violations, the Editorial Board will follow the guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) to determine appropriate further action.

Possible actions include:

  1. Correction (Erratum/Corrigendum): Issued when an article contains minor errors or honest omissions that do not invalidate its main findings.
  2. Expression of Concern: Issued when there is inconclusive evidence of research or publication misconduct, or while an investigation is ongoing.
  3. Retraction: Issued when an article’s findings are deemed unreliable due to research or publication misconduct, honest errors, plagiarism, or redundant publication.

All post-publication notices, including corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions, will be directly linked to the original article to ensure transparency and preserve the integrity of the scholarly record.